banner

A quiet fight at COP31 over carbon-credit rules could reprice India’s climate finance

A first draft decision in Antalya asks the UN crediting body to test whether its own safeguards are too strict. India sits in a bloc raising concerns, even as its domestic carbon market begins to bite.

As COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, entered its final days, one of the sharper disputes was not about fossil fuels or finance headlines. It was about the technical rulebook of the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism, the UN-run carbon market created under Article 6.4. A first draft decision would ask the mechanism’s Supervisory Body to assess how its conservative assumptions, taken together, affect the number of credits issued, their costs and their prices.

The stated aim is to stop conservative adjustments piling up. The draft is still being negotiated, and it carries no figures on credit volumes or prices.

Who Wants What

Dozens of countries have called for the review. According to Climate Home’s sources, the Like-Minded Group of Developing Countries, which includes Saudi Arabia, India and China, joined least developed and landlocked countries in closed talks to argue that the combined requirements on project developers could hinder implementation. Singapore and some Latin American countries stressed projects’ financial viability, and South Korea asked for proportionate requirements.

The EU, Switzerland and Senegal oppose assessing project profitability or lowering standards. Environmental groups agree. Erika Lennon of the Center for International Environmental Law called loosening the rules a “license to pollute”.

Why Integrity Is The Sticking Point

Critics point to a 2024 Nature Sustainability study suggesting cookstove projects may have received about ten times more credits than justified. In October the Supervisory Body made cookstove developers set aside credits in a buffer pool against the risk that forests they claim to protect later burn or are cut down, and rejected exemption requests from developers, corporate buyers, some environmental groups and UNEP.

Industry argues that the conservative approach systematically understates credits and can make projects unviable. That is an industry claim, not an established figure. India is both a likely seller of credits and an exporter exposed to Europe’s carbon border levy.

India’s Two Hats

Indian government’s position on this specific draft was not in the reporting we found. What is clear is that its interests pull in two directions.

As a potential supplier, India has an Article 6.2 arrangement with Japan under the Joint Crediting Mechanism and has said it wants to trade internationally transferred mitigation outcomes. Cheaper, easier credit issuance could widen what Indian developers can sell.

As an exporter, India is exposed to the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism. IISD notes that CBAM allows importers to deduct a carbon price effectively paid in the country of origin, but only conditionally and partially. India’s domestic market is now generating that evidence: about 490 industrial facilities across seven sectors completed their first compliance reporting cycle under the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme in July 2026.

Our reading, not a reported position, is that a rulebook seen as lax would hand Brussels reason to discount carbon prices paid elsewhere, which is the opposite of what Indian exporters want. Cheaper supply and credible pricing do not obviously come together.

What To Watch

Three things will tell the story once the text closes. First, whether the review stays an assessment or becomes a mandate to change rules. Second, whether the cookstove buffer decision survives. Third, how credit buyers read the signal: if integrity is up for negotiation, quality-sensitive buyers may pay more for credits from outside the mechanism.

The wider COP31 picture is also unsettled. The Like-Minded group said the overall draft crosses its red lines on an electrification target, a fossil-fuel transition roadmap and methane reductions, so a package deal could still reshape how carbon-market language lands.

For Indian project developers and industrial buyers preparing for CCTS compliance, the practical point is simple. The price of a credit is partly a political outcome, and it is being negotiated this week.

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *